Deciphering the noise: What market volatility may be telling investors

Political shifts, AI-driven market rotations, and rising uncertainty are testing investors’ resolve, but disciplined strategies remain grounded in long-term fundamentals.

Key takeaways

  • Market volatility does not necessarily signal a change in long-term fundamentals. Recent swings may reflect a recalibration of investor expectations rather than a breakdown in economic or corporate performance.
  • The AI investment story remains intact, but valuations are under greater scrutiny. Investors are increasingly focused on whether AI-related spending is translating into sustainable earnings, cash flow, and shareholder returns.
  • Markets appear to be rotating, not retreating. Capital has begun flowing into sectors such as healthcare, consumer staples, and software, suggesting a broadening market rather than a wholesale exit from equities.
  • Periods of uncertainty may create opportunities. Volatility may provide a valuable opportunity to reassess portfolio allocations, liquidity needs, and alignment with long-term financial objectives.
  • Maintaining a long-term perspective remains critical. Historical trends show markets have often delivered positive returns in the year following elections, reinforcing the importance of staying focused on enduring investment goals rather than short-term headlines.

Markets appear to have become increasingly unpredictable following political shifts, domestic and global disruptions in transportation and communications, and questions surrounding the headline-making AI industry. The thousand-point swings may leave some investors feeling a bit uneasy and questioning what may lie around the next corner. However, more experienced investors may be focused on a different question: Has anything fundamentally changed, and what opportunities might emerge with the tumultuous swings?

“Trying to build a narrative around this market is really challenging,” notes Alan McKnight, Chief Investment Officer at Regions Bank in a recent interview with the New York Times.

This most recent wave of market volatility in the wake of the mid-term elections has challenged conventional expectations and heightened uncertainty across asset classes. For high-net-worth investors, these periods may provide particularly valuable moments to review portfolio strategy, revisit liquidity needs, and evaluate whether current allocations still align with long-term objectives. While volatility may create discomfort, it can also create strategic advantages for those with a disciplined plan.

“To borrow from Winston Churchill, ‘This is not the end. It is not even the beginning of the end. But it is, perhaps, the end of the beginning,’” says McKnight, harkening back to an oft and aptly used quote of his to describe the resilience of a changing market environment. While the circumstances vary, market volatility has become a bit of a norm, with McKnight delivering the keynote speech at the CFA Society Shanghai’s first learning and development webinar hosted in English in 2022. In his title speech, The End of the Beginning, McKnight spoke of the cyclical nature of the markets. The drivers may differ but the emphasis to focus on the fundamentals remains.

Of this latest wave, McKnight notes “I think the end of the beginning being the beginning of this wave of volatility as the market tries to transition from an artificial intelligence, hyper scalar type of market driven outcome to a more sustainable return driven environment.”

The rise and fall (and rise again) of AI?

“Markets are sending an important message,” says McKnight. “Despite strong earnings and continued evidence that AI adoption remains real, scalable, and economically meaningful, investors have been selling many of the very companies leading the AI revolution.”

He shares that the story isn’t that AI is failing, rather that the expectations had become nearly impossible to exceed. “Over the past two years, markets priced AI beneficiaries for perfection. What we’re seeing now is a repricing from ‘how much can they grow?’ to ‘how much growth is already embedded in stock prices?’”

As McKnight’s team has discussed in recent market outlooks, valuations across U.S. equities remain near historic extremes, rivaling many of the most elevated periods in modern market history. At those valuation levels, even excellent earnings can disappoint investors if they fail to exceed increasingly aggressive assumptions.

The recent market reactions to companies such as Apple, Amazon and Alphabet highlight that dynamic. McKnight notes that investors are no longer simply rewarding AI spending. They’re scrutinizing returns on that spending, margins, monetization timelines, and whether hundreds of billions of dollars in AI-related capital expenditures will ultimately generate sufficient shareholder returns.

“That does not mean the AI investment cycle is ending,” says McKnight. “In fact, the underlying economic data suggests the opposite. Business investment, particularly in technology infrastructure, software, intellectual property, and data center development, remains one of the strongest areas of the U.S. economy and continues supporting productivity growth.”

Are AI valuations reconnecting with reality?

According to McKnight, the secular AI story remains intact. “Demand for computer power remains robust and corporate investment trends remain healthy,” he shared during a recent appearance on The Claman Countdown. “Earnings growth among many AI beneficiaries continues to accelerate. However, the market is transitioning from indiscriminate enthusiasm toward a much more selective phase where winners must consistently prove that AI spending is translating into durable cash flow and profit growth.”

McKnight shares that his team is also seeing signs that this is becoming less of a market-wide risk event and more of a rotation. “While AI leaders have struggled, market breadth has improved materially in recent weeks, with money flowing into healthcare, consumer staples, software, and areas of the market that have lagged the AI trade.” That suggests investors may be repositioning rather than abandoning equities altogether.

“This looks less like the end of the AI boom and more like the market’s first serious attempt to separate AI winners from AI hype,” says McKnight. “The benefits remains compelling. It is the valuation story is what’s changing.”

The bottom line

McKnight reminds investors to keep the long game in mind.

“We continue to believe that the U.S. is the best house in a bad neighborhood in global equities and we like the broadening of the market to include small and mid-cap,” he says. “The one caveat is rising rates which could curtail returns in small caps where the cost of capital is higher.”

There is no S&P target for year-end, but long-term market fundamentals remain constructive. McKnight reminds investors that in 14 of the last 15 elections, the S&P has gone higher by double digits a year later. “We have seen consistently higher volume following mid-term elections, but those investments have typically yielded rewards later down the line.”


Talk with your wealth advisor about:

  1. Whether your current investment strategy is aligned with your long-term wealth and legacy goals.
  2. Estate planning strategies to consider during volatile market periods.
  3. Navigating your retirement plan when markets shift.

Looking for professional guidance with wealth planning?
Find an advisor in your area or get started on your journey via our wealth management guide.


Frequently asked questions

Several factors are contributing to recent market swings, including political developments, economic uncertainty, changing interest rate expectations, and shifting investor sentiment around artificial intelligence-related investments.

Not necessarily. According to Alan McKnight, the underlying case for AI remains strong. What appears to be changing is investor willingness to pay premium valuations without clear evidence that AI investments will generate long-term profits and cash flow.

Rather than making emotional reactions to short-term market movements, investors may benefit from reviewing their asset allocation, liquidity needs, risk tolerance, and long-term financial objectives to ensure their strategy remains appropriate.

A market rotation occurs when investors shift capital from one group of stocks or sectors to another. Recent activity suggests some investors are moving beyond AI-focused companies and into sectors that may offer more attractive valuations or defensive characteristics.

Market volatility can present both risks and opportunities for investors to rebalance portfolios, evaluate tax strategies, and evaluate investment opportunities that might arise as market valuations change. Investors with a disciplined plan are often better positioned to navigate uncertain markets.

Investors may want to look beyond headlines and consider fundamentals such as earnings growth, cash flow generation, competitive positioning, monetization strategies, and the potential return on AI-related spending.

While no one can predict market performance with certainty, Alan McKnight notes that historical data has often shown positive returns following election cycles. Long-term investors may benefit from focusing on fundamentals rather than attempting to time market movements.